Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:clap:
 
©2009 ^Cedarseed
:iconcedarseed:

Artist's Comments

Note: I was too squeezed for time to develop the stamp properly, so it is subject to improvement – feel free to comment on it or on the campaign below if you have additional ideas.

The Scrapbook, which appears in the list of categories you can submit a new deviation to, is not used the way it was meant to be, resulting in galleries choked with pieces that should not be there. The masters preserved their scraps carefully, but they knew better than to throw them up alongside their masterpieces. Why would anyone think it's a good thing to have a gallery where one needs to wade through scraps to find a polished piece? What do they think such a "portfolio" says about their abilities? And what do they think dA looks like to an outside visitor? Clearly we, collectively, need to rehabilitate scraps.

The way I see it there are two main reasons why deviants are reluctant to post in scraps:

1. There seems to be a defensive attitude, especially among younger members, about placing anything in the scrapbook, as if that folder was unworthy of anything they can produce. This is an unnecessary prejudice about a word whose only sin is to rhyme with "crap" (it happens to the best of us.) A scrapbook, or sketchbook, is just this: a place for spontaneous jottings and sketches that are not meant to be taken to completion. It's where you can be really free. It allows you to post things that may be cool but would bring the overall quality of your gallery down – things that you want your friends to see but wouldn't leave out of your portfolio. dA introduced the scrapbook so that such things could be posted despite their not meeting the standards all other art communities impose. Seriously, your scrapbook deserves some love. It's time people understood it is not a dumpster, but a place that allows you to be sloppy within the site without compromising the standard of the galleries – that is, it would be if it was put to good use. What you can do about this:
- Use your scrapbook the way it's meant to be used!
- Report scraps the same way you report miscats.
- Use the stamp to spread the word.

2. We all know scraps don't get as much exposure, because they are not automatically activated when you devwatch someone. As a result, people prefer to post a regular deviation and later (maybe) move it to scraps. The desire for whatever you post to be seen is understandable, but this is only a patch, not a solution. Hopefully in the future the scraps activation will be automatic, but that doesn't mean we should just sit and wait for it to happen:
- Remember to activate scraps when you add someone to your watch, and perhaps even let them know that you did this as part of the effort to rehabilitate the use of the Scrapbook.
- Ask your watchers to watch your scraps if they want to see everything you post, because you'll be using them for looser work.
- Use the stamp ;) Here are other stamps that feel the same way:
[link] [link] [link] [link]

Above all remember: this is about educating fellow deviants into using the Scrapbook, not about harrassing them for not doing so! Now go forth and spread the good word :XD:

Comments


love 0 0 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconzeldalina:
:clap: Well said!

--
My avatar was made by me, myself and I in Corel Photo Paint 7 after I scanned my original drawing. :) The Transparency was done in GIMP 2.6.6. ;)
:iconthiefoworld:
:#1: !!

--
Jonathan Castillo
Gallery Moderator of Cartoons & Comics
thiefoworld@volunteers.deviantart.com
:icondaisies-and-vervain:
Love it. ^^
I think I actually have almost as many scraps as legit deviations...
:icontouchedvenus:
Very awesome stamp~ :heart:

--
Check out my contests! Awesome prizes inside!
Sanguem Deus Contest 13: Earth Tones
Draw Sapphirine Contest
:icona-drawer-4ever:
Agreed!

I have to activate my scraps section everytime I watch someone. (I also have to "unfriend" them, if I don't know an artist personally)

But really I think scraps are sometimes my favorite works by artists, because simple things can bring smiles and get ideas across as well!

Perhaps dA could have a separate category in the message centre for scraps, like have "new deviations" and "new scraps". :shrug:

Anyway, great points!

--
I firmly believe one of modern civilization's greatest inventions has been indoor plumbing. :toilet:
:icondraze:
just wish they would open up the feature to use stamps for non-subscribers. I swear back in the day I could do it....

:+fav: for use later.

--
comment, to get comments.
share your kindness, not your hate.
love the art, before yourself.
:iconterrorcookie:
I have more material in my scraps than in my gallery. :b

I try to save the best for my gallery. :heart:

--
:snowflake::snowflake::snowflake:
:snowflake::rose::snowflake:
:snowflake::snowflake::snowflake:
:iconzephroth:
I realy need to feed it a bit more. I dont submit most things on deviant art that im not proud of. in other words if its not complete to my standards i dont post it. I realy should and just post it to scraps.

--
"Power leads to corruption, both are inevitable."
Zephroth Derusus Talinguard
:iconcyname:
I end up with many more unfinished ideas than I do complete ones-so I am a big fan of the scrapbook on here.

And my great artists' Friends on here I do watch their scraps/scrapbook sections. Inspiration comes that way too :D

--
:pray:"I would rather live my life as if there is a God and die to find out there isn't, than live my life as if there isn't and die to find out there is. ":pray: A Camus

:beer:Howzit Brew! How is it? It's good stuff!:beer:
:iconshannanigan:
Recently I have been using my Scrapbook to post rough character sheets and collages of my process (WIPs), inspirations and Close-up details of completed Illustrations. I figure someone might find that sort of thing interesting... :D

I'm not really a loose sketcher. I work out my issues as I'm creating something, so not much to show in the traditional sketchbook/studies sense. I do have a few old things in there that I can't bring myself to delete though. ;)

--
I support CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM... and Just say NO to OctiPorn!!!!

Details

February 24
18.0 KB
18.0 KB
99×56

Statistics

68
116 [who?]
1,640 (0 today)
32 (0 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map